..if this page looks jacked up in your email window, click the link below. (or cut and paste if clicking does nothing) http://www.arseniclullabies.com/newsletter20221212.html

FIRST OFF...come see us at Comic-Con International at out usual booth

We'll have a new issue of Arsenic Lullaby...which I will tell you all about next week.


For now though... 

Let's vandalize a 70 year old comic book!


If you're a collector of comic books or have been to a comic book convention, you know what a "sketch cover" is. If not...it's a "variant" version of an issue where the cover is blank except for maybe the logo.

The point being you can take that version to your favorite artist and have them draw on that cover.


Depending on who it is, how much time they have, how much $$$ you are willing to give them...you could have a quick sketch or something very involved.

 Publishers put these out regularly these days, and for a cheap ploy to get people to buy the same issue twice, it's actually a fun idea...IN THEORY. The problem arises from time to time of the publisher not understanding that not all paper is created equal and some paper is no f8cking good to try to draw or paint on. You don't need to be an artist of any kind to understand that, right? There's a difference between using a pencil on a post it note and trying to use one on a glossy magazine cover. When you are using ink or paint...then it's an even bigger issue.

Most of the time now, publishers get it and make sure the paper for sketch covers is quality stuff that's fairly good to work on. But I've had covers handed to me that you could only use a sharpie marker on, because anything else would come right off as soon as it was touched...ink would just bead up on it like rain on a windshield.

ANYWAYS...that's what sketch covers are.

I recently saw an article trying to figure out what was the first ever sketch cover. They more or less decided on a cover from a DC comic from 1994...though it wasn't created to be sketched on, it was blank, and has been used for sketching.

...they did some good research, but are incorrect.

By their and conventional wisdom's loose parameters of what a sketch cover is, their "first" is about 40 years late to take the crown. I present to you...Panic no.6


1955 by the same publisher as Mad Magazine ( both Mad and Panic were comic book sized at the time and being published as sister titles). At the time, Bill Gaines, the publisher of Mad, Tales from the Crypt, Weird Science, and a bunch of other books was being raked over the coals and even dragged before congress because jackasses, with no life who needed to feel important, were screaming and yelling that horror comics were too offensive and corrupting the youth (everything is a cycle, those people had kids who thought heavy metal music turned you into a Satanist, who had kids who thought grand theft auto was too violent, who had kids who think stand up comedians should get cancelled for jokes, who will have kids who will bitch about some other thing. Not sure what will be left at that point, but don't worry they'll think of something. Take it from someone who started out having the "right" bitch about his comics and now has the "left" bitch about them. It's the right or left really, it's all just a particular lineage of asshole...and they just arbitrarily pick a cause). The point being, Gaines got fed up with people bitching that covers like this should be banned....


and put out an issue of Panic that was blank, as a joke. Previous to that by a couple months he had also put out an issue of Mad with an empty cover, sort of...


but whichever of these you think is more legitimately blank...these were the first blank/sketch covers.

SO...you can find these if you look hard and want to pay some $$$, and you COULD attempt to draw on this 70 year old paper. But...you'd really be pushing your luck. I mean, that'd be a nightmare! Even copies of these in good shape have issues..


You wouldn't be drawing on ONE kind of problematic paper. The paper would be dyer at the edges, parts would still be shiny, other parts be rough and fragile. Some of it would have the ink beading up and other parts would absorb the ink like tissue paper and make it bleed at the edges. You would not be able to use any kind of pen because the tip would dig in and crease or dig in and bleed.

and if you think you'd be able to use regular ink on this I have three letters for you..L...O...L. You'd probably have to use some kind of acrylic ink for parts and some kind of paint for other parts. or some kind of hybrid paint/ink. In some spots you'd need it thick, in other spot watery. Which is another reason you wouldn't want to use a pen, even a brush pen. You'd have to test and practice on another cover of a book that old, because you are only getting one shot. It's not like you can use white out.

Yeah...you'd have to not only be a master, but so full of hubris that you're a borderline egomaniac. One who is willing to possibly destroy a rare golden age comic book to test his skill. I am all of those things, so...

I picked a scene/character I've done before (several times actually for one reason or another) and am comfortable with, so at least that aspect won't be a struggle. This character, by the way, is one I had done for an issue of Mad Magazine and technically EC comics...so it's pretty legit having me draw on this. EC comic sketched on by EC artist.


That's gonna be tough, ain't it. The buildings need be straight lines and done with a brush. It'll need varying line thickness to give depth, which mean heavy inking on fragile paper. It has some details that are small and who the hell knows how the brush itself is going to flex or drag on parts of this.


Off we go.

It did not take long for this to become nerve wracking and...possibly a stupid idea. Like I said...this is really several kinds of paper. Some of it does NOT want to take the ink and some of it is so fragile that a brush stroke might take a piece right off.

You see (pic above) how the line for the building is dark and the lines for the clouds (lower left hand side) are gray and faded looking? That's not the paint/ink...that's the paper. That's how different the paper itself is and is taking in the ink, from one spot to the next.

well...we've come this far. Let's see how much we can do before disaster strikes.


at this point, another issue is becoming a problem. Aside from the structural integrity of the paper being inconsistent, the paper is wavy and has buckled from moisture or age or who knows what. So, it's not even f8cking flat, and a brush does not push the paper down as you go..it either rides up and down or SPREADS OUT on the bumps, giving you a thicker line than you meant. Making one line a consistent thickness in one stroke...not happening. That is going to make inking those building a real problem. Okay, we'll just keep that in mind and do our best.

Just drawing on this with a pencil was giving me an idea of how problematic some parts of the paper were going to be. I left some of that til the end when I at least a little experience with this nightmare. 


Needed the ink/paint to be rather thick on the edges and tears so as to not bleed, and it was sticking to the paper a little bit and could have pulled brittle parts right off. BUT, not so far.



I had some ideas for the background, but I'm REALLY pushing my luck at this point, every line is another chance to ruin a 70yr old comic book. And honestly, the paper is too fragile. If you've ever held a newspaper or magazine or comic that old, you know they're brittle and can crack pretty easy just flipping pages. Much more dangerous resting your hand on it and moving it around to draw lines. Doing the affects I wanted... would have me sliding my hand back and forth over and over until eventually, probably as I am finishing the very last line, I'd hear a "riiiiipppp".

So, I'm going to stop here and take the win.


THAT was nerve wracking, but looks pretty darn cool I'd say. Part of me wants to erase the pencil lines, but I don't think the paper could handle it. And That might be enough to pull some of the ink off or at least lighten it. I'm gonna leave well enough alone. Oh...I did the Mad cover also.

And another Panic cover...just for the sake of spiking the football.

Actually grabbed up a bunch of copies these issues. A bit of that was for pure investment purposes, because it's a safe bet that other illustrators, or sketch cover collectors will see this and try to get these issues...and it's also a safe bet many get ruined while trying to be sketched on, hahahaha. Every failed attempt tips the law of supply and demand in my favor.

Since these are rare, golden age, historical comics, I had them "graded". What a grading service does is verify that the book is it what it is (believe it or not, there are counterfitters out there. Especially of indy stuff, where the original production value is easier to duplicate TMNT no.1 and Cerebus no.1 come to mind as issues people have made faux copies off), verify the signature or sketch was done by who you say it was, and/or how good the condition of the book is ( and it gets sealed up with the verification on it.).  CBCS are the people I use for grading, I've known one of the main guys Cody Lockwood forr several years andd he knows his stuff.

So...thanks to the team at CBCS for grading these



Anyways...see you at Comic-Con International, Booth 2200!



Sign up for the A.L. Email updates Sign up for the A.L. Email updates

Get a weekly-ish email from the writer illustrator of Arsenic Lullaby.  Some week's it's a sneak preview, or a long rant, or news about new projects before we tell anyone else, or a discount code.